# Skylights vs. sun tunnels without the leaks

Source: https://roofingbyskyline.com/blog/skylights-vs-sun-tunnels

> Fixed, venting and curb-mounted skylights and tubular sun tunnels suit different rooms and roofs. How to choose, and why the flashing matters most.

Published 2024-06-27 · Updated 2026-10-11 · Roofing

A skylight can transform a dark kitchen or hallway. It’s also the most common place for a roof to leak — not because skylights are inherently leaky, but because the flashing around them is so often done wrong. Here’s how to choose the right unit, and what a good installation looks like.

*Photo: Cutaway illustration of fixed, venting and curb-mounted skylights and a tubular sun tunnel.*

## The options

- **Fixed skylights** — the simplest and most common. Steady daylight for living rooms, stairwells and lofts.
- **Venting skylights** — open manually or with a motor to release heat and moisture. Great for kitchens and bathrooms.
- **Curb-mounted skylights** — sit on a raised curb, which makes them the right choice for **flat and low-slope roofs** and for replacing existing units.
- **Tubular sun tunnels** — a small dome on the roof and a reflective tube down to a ceiling diffuser. Ideal for closets, interior bathrooms and hallways where a full skylight won’t fit between framing.

*Photo: Soft, diffused daylight from a ceiling skylight in a small sitting room.*

## How to choose

| Feature      | Skylight                      | Sun tunnel               |
| ------------ | ----------------------------- | ------------------------ |
| Light        | Broad, with sky views         | Bright, diffused         |
| Rooms        | Living areas, kitchens, lofts | Closets, baths, hallways |
| Framing      | May require cutting rafters   | Fits between framing     |
| Ventilation  | Available (venting models)    | No                       |
| Install time | Typically a day               | Typically a few hours    |

For energy performance, look for double- or triple-glazed, low-E glass and an insulated curb. In sunnier parts of the Bay Area, shades or tinted glazing help control heat gain.

## The flashing is the installation

Glass rarely leaks. Flashing does. A watertight skylight needs:

- **The manufacturer’s flashing kit** for your roof type — shingle, tile, metal or flat — not a bead of sealant
- **Self-adhered membrane** around the curb, lapped correctly with the underlayment
- **Proper framing** for the new opening
- **Integration with the roofing** so water above the unit is diverted around it

*Photo: Skyline crew installing several skylights on a San Francisco roof.*

## Repairing an existing skylight

If an older skylight leaks or fogs, the fix is often at the flashing rather than the unit itself. Fogged or cracked domes and single-pane units are usually worth replacing with modern low-E glass — and if a reroof is coming, replacing skylights at the same time is the most cost-effective path.

Thinking about more daylight, or dealing with a skylight leak? [Let’s take a look](https://roofingbyskyline.com/contact).

## Contact

- Phone: (415) 209-5199 (+1-415-209-5199)
- Email: info@roofingbyskyline.com
- Hours: Monday–Friday, 8am–5pm
- Service area: San Francisco and the greater Bay Area — San Francisco, The Peninsula, The East Bay, The South Bay, Marin
- License: California C-39 Roofing, CSLB #1138836 (verify: https://www.cslb.ca.gov/OnlineServices/CheckLicenseII/CheckLicense.aspx)
- Request a free assessment: https://roofingbyskyline.com/contact
