Skip to content

Roofing · 2 min read

Skylights vs. sun tunnels without the leaks

Fixed, venting and curb-mounted skylights and tubular sun tunnels suit different rooms and roofs. How to choose, and why the flashing matters most.

By The Skyline team · · Updated

A skylight can transform a dark kitchen or hallway. It’s also the most common place for a roof to leak — not because skylights are inherently leaky, but because the flashing around them is so often done wrong. Here’s how to choose the right unit, and what a good installation looks like.

Cutaway illustration of fixed, venting and curb-mounted skylights and a tubular sun tunnel.

The options

  • Fixed skylights — the simplest and most common. Steady daylight for living rooms, stairwells and lofts.
  • Venting skylights — open manually or with a motor to release heat and moisture. Great for kitchens and bathrooms.
  • Curb-mounted skylights — sit on a raised curb, which makes them the right choice for flat and low-slope roofs and for replacing existing units.
  • Tubular sun tunnels — a small dome on the roof and a reflective tube down to a ceiling diffuser. Ideal for closets, interior bathrooms and hallways where a full skylight won’t fit between framing.
Soft, diffused daylight from a ceiling skylight in a small sitting room.

How to choose

FeatureSkylightSun tunnel
LightBroad, with sky viewsBright, diffused
RoomsLiving areas, kitchens, loftsClosets, baths, hallways
FramingMay require cutting raftersFits between framing
VentilationAvailable (venting models)No
Install timeTypically a dayTypically a few hours

For energy performance, look for double- or triple-glazed, low-E glass and an insulated curb. In sunnier parts of the Bay Area, shades or tinted glazing help control heat gain.

The flashing is the installation

Glass rarely leaks. Flashing does. A watertight skylight needs:

  • The manufacturer’s flashing kit for your roof type — shingle, tile, metal or flat — not a bead of sealant
  • Self-adhered membrane around the curb, lapped correctly with the underlayment
  • Proper framing for the new opening
  • Integration with the roofing so water above the unit is diverted around it
Skyline crew installing several skylights on a San Francisco roof.

Repairing an existing skylight

If an older skylight leaks or fogs, the fix is often at the flashing rather than the unit itself. Fogged or cracked domes and single-pane units are usually worth replacing with modern low-E glass — and if a reroof is coming, replacing skylights at the same time is the most cost-effective path.

Thinking about more daylight, or dealing with a skylight leak? Let’s take a look.

Talk to someone who’s been on the roof.

Free assessments across the Bay Area. Written, fixed-price proposals.

Request an assessmentor call (415) 209-5199
Free assessment

Let’s keep the water out — for good.

Tell us what’s going on. We’ll inspect, explain what we find with photos, and give you a written, fixed-price proposal — usually within 48 hours of the visit.